On the Threshold
A critical essay by Roberta Bertozzi on the work of Erich Turroni, read as a meditation on the human figure at the edge of visibility. Bodies, faces and anatomical fragments emerge as fragile presences, suspended between matter and disappearance, surface and depth, wound and apparition.
If only we too could find a human thing,
pure, contained, narrow,
a strip of fertile land of our own
between river and rock. For our heart transcends us
still, as it transcended them. And we can no longer
pursue it in images where it might grow calm, nor
in divine bodies where, greater, it might be tempered.
— Rainer Maria Rilke
I am of the view that Erich Turroni's research tends, taken as a whole, to take the form of a powerful, implacable elegy of the human. If I borrow this word from the literary sphere, it is to signal the surprising affinity between his gesture and the one that brings about poetic revelation. Elegiac, to begin with, is the trajectory of his style, calibrated on withdrawal rather than action, dominated by a reserve, an expressive modesty so rigorous as to exclude any residue of subjective intention; but elegiac above all is the perspective from which he observes his object, the way in which it becomes manifest, as if it were an obsolete, lost matter, and he were there to circumscribe its last glimmer. For the human figure, the exclusive leitmotif of his work, bears here the mark of a posthumous condition, the signature of a twilight; it takes shape as something resigned in an immeasurable distance, closed in the perfect sorrowfulness of a farewell.
In this respect his inquiry could constitute the potential extension, if not the final stage, of an entire tendency of modern thought that has intensely questioned the very possibility of the human in the face of the general anthropological crisis that marked the twentieth century, after the genocides and the world wars, in the progressive subjection of every ethical instance to the principles of mercantile production and in the irreversible massification set in motion by contemporary economic and media systems. The humanity that populates these canvases seems to make that thought physical, to reflect its same apprehension for the fate of the species: blurred, wounded, soluble bodies, limbs and faces; perhaps only luminescences, psychic fields, traces offered as the echo of a being, the friable, worn-out cast of what once was, presumably, somewhere and at some time, a person – the person.
Unmoored from any ideological model, archetypal reference or futurizing hypothesis, the subject of Turroni's work is exposed in all its metaphysical nakedness, an absolute emblem of a post-human context in which individuals have been stripped of any function, the singular physis has become hybrid, and the body, once a center of identitarian individuation, a mere commodity of exchange. Neither generic nor specific, much less biological or historical, it is fundamentally a disoriginated being, reduced to its own minimum, to the pure literalness of its contour – infra-thin, a minuscule partition of shadow.

A shadow that turns into a threshold, into a hint: what survives here of the person is solely its instantaneous occurring, the precarious becoming of a presence. It is on the fixing of these fleeting epiphanies that his gesture persists: on the repeated attempt to capture a movement, a duration, to detach it from the infinity of the background into which every form seems invariably destined to flow back. If, as Jean-Luc Nancy has written, bodies signify themselves, singularize themselves, identify themselves precisely in the act of passing, if the person is "its arrival and its departure", in these works that sequence seems to sharpen, the temporality of representation becomes extremely brief, millimetric, and often the gesture manages to hold on to nothing more than silhouettes still in germ, ectoplasmic semblances, patches like fetal sketches whose process of coagulation has been incautiously arrested. Or the framing is forced to narrow onto limited anatomical sections, glimpses, stumps, thus disintegrating the bodies into autonomous segments, symptomatically more eloquent than any completed physiognomy.
In other words, the composition always settles in such a way as to leave us baffled before what is offered to our gaze, struck by a sort of optical uncertainty, unable to tell whether these figures are stepping forward or withdrawing, whether the impulse they follow is that of a genesis or of a disintegration. Not without the impression that these directions subsist simultaneously, like two contrary movements harmonizing within a system of forms that remains reluctant to solidify – fluid, unstable. It is a phenomenon triggered by the very executive rhythm of his practice, by the different, calculated phases it requires. By his proceeding through stratifications, beginning with a first laying down of color fields on the support, already the condition for the appearance of a silhouette, to which are added the drawing and the inclusion of further glazes, further transparencies: a superimposition of planes that unexpectedly keeps intact the reversible character of the figuration. The final pour of resin, a sort of glassy seal affixed to the whole, rather than acting as a stabilizer is the propulsive agent of this flou effect: it interacts with the previous layers, reanimates them by altering their chromatic values, amplifies the evanescence of the image, with the result of returning it to its original indeterminacy.
As in a photographic proof whose development has been halted at a precise moment, the outcome is that of a body in emergence, floating, suspended at the water's surface: the very lines traced in pencil or pen, which should delimit its features, often end up dilating its liquidity, its tremor: they grow complicated, snag, skid off in a centrifugal motion, as if unable to discipline what continues to be drawn by an intrinsic sinking – stones thrown into a body of water, once again a further stirring.

The metaphor of surfacing, of emergence, of a human quid that occurs only on the threshold, in a contiguity of surface, is, I believe, ultimately the one in which the semantic values of his work are best qualified. Human bodies without specific weight, lacking consistency, diluted: every trace of them seems to thicken in the form of a patina, to clot into an epidermal density. This oscillation on the superficial layer, quite explicit in the pictorial works, finds its counterpart in the sculptural ones too, indeed gaining in them an intensive drama, a greater pressure. Before us stand limbs and heads of massive, monumental proportions, in violent counterpoint to the slender handwriting of the paintings, granite physiques, fossils unearthed from who knows what recesses. Yet, despite this imposingness, the drama they flaunt seems to gather exclusively on their outer covering, tormented, corroded, karstic, a sign of a travail consumed in far other depths. This pitted, rough skin reveals a labor of excavation pushed pathologically into the very grain of the matter, as if to extract from it a remnant of soul, a final tremor.
If Turroni's poetics expresses itself in finding a paradigm for the human, something that might attest anew to its existence, I tend to think that it is summed up in this skin, where being can still index itself, give a sign of itself as density and as tension – where it can, in a word, exist. A skin/soul in which the last line of demarcation of the body endures, the last, minimal synecdoche of a physicality, of a presence. A cicatricial skin, in which all the fractures assemble, the anguished folds of a subjectivity shattered into pieces. A protective shell but also a rim, an edge, an extremity – a point of contact and junction with the world, with other bodies, other derma.
If Erich Turroni's human figures are expropriated of every sign, of every individualizing trait, it is to allow them to appropriate belonging itself, to defend this last fragment of essence, pure, contained, narrow – to mark its basic boundary, with a splendidly elementary lyrical efficacy.
Roberta Bertozzi
On the Threshold
notes on the work of Erich Turroni
Originally published in the exhibition catalogue Erich Turroni. “de visu”
edited by Marisa Zattini, Il Vicolo, Cesena, Italy, 2012
Galleria Comunale d’Arte, Palazzo del Ridotto, Cesena, 20 October to 11 November 2012.
Part of the project Ciò che ci rende umani, conceived by Teatro Valdoca in collaboration with the Culture Department of the Municipality of Cesena.
Critical essay by Roberta Bertozzi
IG roberta_artview ↗︎
